Copyright © 2019 Henrietta W. Hay
Banning Harry Potter!?! NO!!
November 23, 2001
Nearly every kid in America and half the world has read about Harry Potter, and by the time this gets printed, several million of them will have seen the movie, "Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone." I am going to skip the movie for now and stick to my mental picture of Harry flying through the air on his Nimbus 4000.
Children's books have been sparking the imagination of kids and bringing them joy for over a century and, to my knowledge no kid has ever been ruined by a fairy tale. The Faultless Starch Co. booklet titled "A Trip to the Moon" from the 1890's is about a boy named Robbie who is taken to the moon on a moonbeam by elves. These booklets were distributed to rural homes by peddlers via horse and wagon. I'll bet my dad read them between chores on the farm in Illinois.
I grew up with lots of witches and goblins and fairies, starting with Mother Goose and Hans Christian Anderson and the Wizard of Oz. I knew that the fairies weren't real, that the Wizard and the Tin Woodman weren't real and that the Wicked Witch of the West got her comeuppance, but somehow I survived that wonderful world of fantasy without serious damage to my psyche, and perhaps it helped me keep some of my child through the years.
The Boomer generation grew up on the same books, with a lot of wonderful new ones. But in spite of the wizards and witches and fairies, all those children who read them hung on to their sense of reality and turned into solid citizens, or most of them did.
But now in the 21st century witches and goblins and fantasy we all grew up with have turned evil according to some adults and are being protested as threats to the children's souls. We have Harry Potter, whom the kids love so dearly, but who scares some of the Muggles.
Several groups of Evangelical Christians are protesting the wonderful fantasy of Harry Potter because they believe that witchcraft is real, and that children are being led into Satanism. Certainly parents who feel that way should not let their children read about Harry or probably anybody else.
But as for the rest of us, when people protest a series of books that has given untold joy and has made wildly enthusiastic readers out of millions of kids, and fans out of millions of adults, that's going too far. According to the American Library Association' statistics, the Potter books topped the banned book list in 2000. I have a major problem with any kind of censorship, but this is beyond ridiculous.
This generation's kid hero is a delightful orphan who finds that he is a wizard and attends the Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. He is a brave, loyal, honest and very smart wizard. Naturally, the good guys always win in the end.
John Monk, an editorial writer in South Carolina got very indignant. "Some claim the Potter books lure children into witchcraft. Poppycock. You might as well say Gone With the Wind teaches young readers to be slave owners, or Peter Pan urges children to run away from home. If we ban these books, a dark force stands to be unleashed. It's not the occult. It's ignorance."
Author Judy Blame, who has had more experience than most with having her much loved children's books censored, protested and torn up was not surprised at the protest. "I knew this was coming. The only surprise is that it took so long for the zealots who claim they're protecting children from evil to discover that children actually like these books.
"At the rate we're going, I can imagine next year's headline: 'Goodnight Moon", Banned for Encouraging Children to Communicate with Furniture."
A hundred years ago Robbie was being taken to the moon on a moonbeam by elves. Now Harry Potter, who is a bona fide wizard, is playing Quiddich, helping his friends when they need it and giving today's electronic whiz kids a taste of adventure that doesn't need batteries. Go for it, kids. Books are here to stay. So is Harry Potter. Go Harry, win that Quiddich game for Gryffindor.